Sunday, September 25, 2011

North Side Brewing History Tour

Early this last week I was running a couple of errands, and I stopped by the Northern Brewer homebrew supply store and picked up another carboy to use as a secondary fermenter. On the counter, next to the register, was a flyer proclaiming "Saturday Sept 24 10AM - 5PM - Urban Archaeology Expedition: Legacies of Milwaukee Brewing: North Side Brewing History Tour".
Now probably 3 years ago, I was hanging out with my friend good friend Tom Frank Jr. at his parents' house (who I also consider my freinds). Tom Sr. tols me about these "Ale through through the Ages" classes that he was attending with one of his other sons at Discovery World. The "class" was about the background of historic styles of beer, as well as how to brew that style at home. Each style had two sessions - a Brewing day and a Bottling day. And on the bottling day, they got to take home a bottle of the beer that had been brewed to represent that style.
 
This sounded very interesting to me, so I looked them up and kept an eye on it. But for one reason or another I never made it to any of the sessions. Last year I had heard that they were doing a South Side Brewing History Tour that I really wanted to go on, but at that time I was tight on cash and couldn't do it. Now I figured I had another chance with the North Side tour. So I got my schedule in order for the rest of the week and called the Discovery World reservation desk to see if there were still any openings (the tour was limited to the first 50 people). Lucky me, there was room for me!
 
So yesterday morning, I rolled up on the beautiful Milwaukee lakefront, parked my car and headed for the front door. There was a charter bus sitting out front for us and I got a goodie bag. I grabbed my seat and looked at what I'd gotten. It was a canvas Discovery world bag (kind of like the ones that are all the rage now with people trying to be more "green") In it was a 22 oz. bottle of the archaeology team's "homebrew" bock "Omnibus". They let us know that it was still very young and had just been bottled. The lager was set to bottle condition, so they advised us to give the bottle some time to mature and finish bottle conditioning. There was also a little bag of Fritos (which I was grateful for later in the day - not because I was hungry, so much as I needed a snack in me after around of sampling - but that's later, so let me not get ahead of myself). Also included was the booklet that outlined the stops that we would be making on our tour and two flyers - one for the fourth season of Ale through the Ages, and one for a fundraising event for the Sailing Vessel Denis Sullivan.
 
I was getting pretty excited already. I was going on a tour that would involve history, Milwaukee and beer (3 of my favorite things), and I'd gotten a bag of freebies. Yay free stuff! (Although technically I paid for the tour, I wasn't expecting the free stuff, so it still counts as a bonus in my book). As we were heading out, Kevin Cullen (one of the two guys guiding us) said that we one of our early stops would be made at the old 1890 Schlitz Brewhouse and we'd have a toast to the building, which is, quite unfortunately, scheduled for demolition. As a toast, they had brought a Corney keg of the bock they'd given us in bottles. The warning came that the beer was still young and that they were doing forced carbonation to have it fairly drinkable. Obviously, I think they would have preferred a beer that had aged a little more, but they didn't have anything else yet. So there was a keg on the bus! Bonus to the bonus! And, honestly, despite being young it was really quite good.
 
So the tour got on and they drove us down Juneau, which used to be known as Brewers Row. They told us that within Milwaukee, over the course of time ther had been about 15 Breweries east of the river and 95 west of it. Not all at the same time, mind you. At it's height, the city had about 30-35 breweries operating at the same time. This was about 1860-1863.
 
We drove to the site of the old Ogden Avenue Union Brewery. Unfortunately, due to city development, there is no building still remaining at that site. It is just an empty gravel lot, because after the demolition, the development fell through. They did indicate that there were likely still chambers remaining somewhere within the hillside, under the sidewalks and maybe under the gravel lot. When I would walk from Schlitz Park to the grocery store up the hill on my lunch break (which I did a number of times while I was working downtown) I would walk right past that location, and I had no idea what was there. In 2005, the structures on the site were removed from the "Historic Designation" by the city, and a developer was given a permit to demolish the buldings to develop condos. The demolition occurred in January 2006, and the hole was filled in in 2011. I may have even walked past it before they demolished the building (I don't recall specifically, since I saw a number of old buildings get torn down and replaced by modern condos the last few years.) How sad.
 
From there we went to the Schlitz Brewery and tapped into the keg to toast the old Schlitz Brewhouse. Now this was right across the parking lot from where I worked, and it is right next to Libiamo's restaraunt. I walked past that building dozens of times. In front of it is where I attended the event to celebrate Schlitz' return to the original recipe and look at classic cars (again, on a lunch break - but who wouldn't go since I had to just walk across a small parking lot). I've always thought the building was very beautiful, despite a somewhat more modern addition on one side of the building, and a parking structure obscuring the view of the rear of the building.
They explained that despite the loss of a beautiful historic landmark, decisions like this are often made because modern property owners find it very difficult to find tennants for brew houses. Without tennants, they don't make the money to rehab the buldings. Without money to rehab, the buildings fall into disrepair and then they are condemned or demolished to be replaced by something that makes money. The problem with trying to repurpose a brewhouse is that there are holes from equipment and the floors are all slanted. Repurposing such a building can be difficult and expensive. And so we lose beautiful landmarks.
 
From there we went a couple of blocks over to the old E.L. Husting Brewery building. The entire bulding complex is still intack and is now considered the oldest standing, complete brewery in Milwaukee, and possibly Wisconsin. There is one other brewery that may be able to compete for that title, because they opened earlier and their buildings still stand. But that brewery experienced a disaster that destroyed the buildings and they had to rebuild.
 
Although the building has been repurposed, it all still stands, with original cream city brick and everything. We were able to go inside to see some of the internal architecture. One place I would have liked to have seen is the basement, which stories say is haunted. One of our tour guides, Leonard, said that one time he had gone downstairs into the basement with a video camera and the camera went dead three times after switching out new batteries. Haunted? Maybe.... (I love little stories like that, even though I don't belive in them)
 
We went up a block to the location of the J. Obermann/Jung Brewery. Now turned into another gravel lot.
 
Then we visited Schlitz Park. Not the business park where I used to work, but the location on N. 8th and W. Vine where a green space was set up with a lookout tower, a hotel, a theater, an open air opera house and became a premier Milwaukee entertainment destination for three decades. After being acquired by the city, the park was renamed and Roosevelt Middle School was built on the site of the park.
 
We stopped outside the Northwestern Brewery / Altpeter Malt House. Fortunately, these buildings still stand, but they were repurposed. We weren't able to go in, but it was pretty cool looking from the outside. We also got to stop outside the Phoenix Brewery / Malt House on the corner of N 2nd St and Vine and the location where the Roedel/Badger Brewery used to be on Reservoir and Hubbard.
 
During these stops, we made a stop at a Miller Brewery "Tide House" that is currently being refurbished and should be opened again as a bar this coming spring. The owner let us in and gave us the nickel tour. I had never heard of tide houses before, but the history is kind of cool. The following is the information that was provided in our booklet said the following:
 
As early as the 1850s, Milwaukee breweries understood the need to work with tavern owners/operators in every possible way to insure that their brand of beer was carried and sold at their establishments. To do so, the breweries offered special proces or discounts on beer, and in many cases, they would help the tavern owner maintain the property by offering new equipment, or sometimes help pay property repairs.
 
Eventually, the breweries discoverd that the best way to keep a saloon/tavern account and grow beer sales, was to focus more on the saloon customer through aggressive advertising and point of sale advertising signs and materials. Finally the breweries discoverd that the most practical way to hold a drinking customer and grow sales was to own the saloon outright, thus eliminating competition altogether. By the 1890s most Milwaukee breweries, especially the larger ones, began an aggressive program to purchase existing saloons, purchase prime vacant locations, and build newer saloons. These saloons became known as "tied houses" because they were "tied" to the breweries.
 
The ownership and control of brewery-owned and controlled saloons/tavers (tied houses) ended when Prohibition was repealed in 1933. The federal government ruled that breweries were only allowed to be involved in the brewing and manufacturing of beer. Moreover, their function and role is not a retailer of beer, thus forcing the breweries to sell or close their taverns. Prior to Prohibition, the Schlitz Brewing Co. had more than 2,000 saloons across the United States, the Pabst Brewing Co. had more than 1,000 saloons. Both the Blatz Brewing Co. and Miller Brewing Co. had much smaller numbers of tide houses. During Prohibition (1920-1933) many of the former "tied houses" operated as ice cream and soda parlors, however a great number operated as "speakeasies", where illegal alcohol was offered and were then commonly called "blind pigs".
 
Today, most of these former tide houses are still standing throughout Milwaukee and are generally identifiably brick with corner doors and located on street corners. many of the buildings still have evidence of what brewery operated the tavern, due to the original painted or inlaid brewery insignias. As an enduring legacy of this tradition, often these former brewery saloons continue to operate as bars or restaurants. (This information proveded by Leonard Jurgensen - Milwaukee Brewery Historian - and Kevin Cullen - Discovery World Archaeologist)
 
On the tour we were also told that Schlitz was so agressive about getting rid of competition that when they put a tide house on a corner, they would also buy the lots on the other three corners to ensure that no competition could put in a tide house.
Lunch was at the Stonefly Brewery / brew pub (formerly Onopa). Before we ate, we grabbed a pint. I started with their their Ol' Seal Away scotch ale. It was 6.5%, nice dark reddish brown. There was little to no head. It had a nice malty charachter with a little bitter finish, and it might have had just a touch of astringency. Overall, it was good, but not the best scotch ale that I've had.
 
Once we had our pints in hand, their head brewer, Jacob Sutrick, took us back to where the magic happens and gave us a quick tour and fielded questions. Last year, Stonefly produced 161 barrels, about 31 batches. They have 10 year round beers and maybe 4 specialty beers. Someone asked him which of their beers is his favorite. His response was that asking that question is like asking a parent which child is their favorite. Someone else on the group said that it should be easy, then. Jacob said that's true, but it's not something you say outloud. Their flagship beer is Moustache Red Pale Ale. After that, it is probably their Four Wolves English Ale.
 
After the tour, we sat down to lunch (included in the price of our tour). This is when I really got to meet other people on the tour. Lunch was a blast. After I finished by Ol' Seal Away, I had the Moustache Red Pale Ale. It was great. I would definately drink it again. Unfortunately, I was too busy chatting with people at my table to take notes about the beer itself. I guess I'll just have to head back to Riverwest and drink some more!
 
Lunch was their Redhot Bleu Burger. It was great. Definately my top 20 burgers.
 
After lunch, we drove by the original location of Lakefront Brewing Company at 818 Chambers St. and past the location where Blatz Park used to be. We stopped outside the location where Milwaukee's Capitol Brewery used to stand (not to be confused with the existing Madison Capital Brewery). This was on our way to Big Bay Brewing Company's tasting room at 4517 North Oakland Ave. Big Bay does not have their own brewery, so they work with Milwaukee Brewing Co. to use their equipment for brewing. This is not contract brewing, Big Bay's people are on site working with Milwaukee Brewing's head brewer to use their equipment. The tasting room is there to build awareness of their beers (and sell merchandise, beer and soda). We sampled Wave Hopper - a Kolsch style, Botilla - their amber, and Long Weekend pale ale. Their Amber was real good.
 
So at this point, the trip has allowed me to check off two points on my brewery bucket list - Stonefly and Big Bay.
 
Then we headed to Sprecher Brewing Co. for a tour. I've done the tour before. It was good, about the same, but the sampling at the end was a great time. One thing I didn't like was that instead of doing 4 paper coupons for free samples they started doing a wrist band with tear-off tabs for the samples. The tabs are void if torn off by anyone other than the bartender. Which means that people who are only drinking soda can't just give away their coupons. Sprecher did this to keep the tour family friendly and discourage people getting smashed. Fortunately, if you make friends with a soda drinker, you can just ask them to hit the bar on your behalf, and you're still golden.
 
We also drove past the buildings of Eline Candy Plant where the failed attempt at candy production occurred during prohibition by the Uihlein family. We also went past the location of Pabst Park. Pabst Park is no longer the park that it once was, but it's still a park to this day.
 
After the tour wrapped up, we headed back to Discovery world and Kevin took us up the back way (because the museum was closed to the public for a wedding) to see their THIRST Lab. It "is Discovery World's newest educational space and Milwaukee's newest nano-scale brewery with its 1-barrel brewing system. The goal of the THIRST Lab is to teach people about the properties of Water by making water-based products - most notably beer!"
 
All in all, it was a fantastic day!

Sunday, September 18, 2011

Food and Beer Pairing

I'm at the Cedarburg wine and harvest festival and at the Cedar Creek Trading Post I found a nice little book - Beer & Food: Great Recipes to Compliment Great Beers. It is divided by beer type and followed by four recipes that should pair well with that style of beer - can't wait to try them out!

Sunday, September 11, 2011

Spring and Summer 2011

Many little things have happened that I haven't taken the time to write about.  I'd like to do a little catching up.

New Beers I've tried -
Milwaukee Ale House - Weisenbock.  I think this was a contest beer that had been made and was put on their menu.  Lucky for me, it was there when we cashed in a Groupon and had lunch there on thier terrace on the river.  It was a fantastic combination of a weiss beer and a bock beer.
Moosehead Lager - Canadian beer.  I enjoyed it, but it was nothing special.  Much like big American beers, but a little better.
Sapporo - Japanese Beer.  It was okay.
Furthermore Three Feet Deep.  It had a nice smokey flavor, but it had a little too much of a roasted flavor.  If they'd taken that down a notch it would have been a really good beer.
Probably a couple of other foreign beers that I don't remember.
Sand Creek Brewing Company - Wild Ride IPA and Hard Lemonade
Fourth of July weekend I brewed my first batch of beer - Northern Brewer's St. Paul Porter.  I messed up using the hydrometer so I have no idea if what the specific gravity actually is.  I know what it should be - just not what my batch also is.  I also had to fudge some of what I was doing because I couldn't use the bottling bucket.  My kit was missing the spigot.  I went to the Northern Brewer store near my home and got a spigot for free, but not until after the beer was in the carboy.  I also ran it as a single fermentation since I didn't have a secondary fermenter.  I'll have to buy myself another carboy so I have a secondary fermenter.  I'll probably buy two, so I can run overlap making two batches.  Bottling day went well.  I had a good bit of prep time because instead of buying a case of bottles, I'd kept all of my pry off bottles, so I had to de-label, clean and sanitize them.  They worked quite well for bottling.  Today they are ready to go into the fridge.
Having used up all of my sanitizer and being done with my first batch of beer, I made a trip today to Northern Brewer.  In having made my first batch, I found that chilling the wort took a long time.  So in addition to sanitizer, I bought a wort chiller.  And a new kit.  I wanted to try one that Amanda would try with me, so I picked up a raspberry wheat beer.  I'll have to make it soon, but not today.
We also did the second anual Brewfest on the Milwaukee lakefront.  They definately learned from last year.  The event was big.  Lots of vendors with lots of good beer.  And enough bathrooms this time.  I had so much fun that I have to admit I didn't take any time to take notes.  I tried plenty of new beers.  Some okay.  Some very good.  I think I took some pictures, so maybe I'll post a little more about it later.
I don't know that I've learned much more about beer.  But I know that I've had some very good beers and have had a lot of fun.

Sunday, April 24, 2011

Modelo

I tried Modelo especial. It had a light, pale, clear amber hue. The scent was light and unobtrusive. It had a solid malty flavor with a hint of bitter and a hint of sour. There was a little sweetness to it. I put it in the Bud Light / MGD category. I don't care for it, but I don't hate it. I won't buy it, but I'd drink it on a hot summer day if it was offered to me.

Lakefront Brewery in Beer Connoisseur Magazine

I was reading the Spring issue of Beer Connoisseur Magazine this afternoon, and another Milwaukee Brewery got a mention in one of its articles! Good job Milwaukee. Great job Lakefront. Thank you Lucy Saunders and thank you Beer Connoisseur!

I was reading the article "A Thirst for Tradition: Craft Brewing & Slow Food" by Lucy Saunders. It was an article about the slow food movement - "meals prepared with fresh ingredients and care, and enjoyed at length, replete with conversation and plenty of conviviality. Slow Food USA focuses on food that is 'Good, Clean and Fair,' i.e., a way of living, eating and drinking that links us to the community and the environment." It also talks about craft beer's relationship to the the slow food movement.

And the author wrote the following about Lakefront: "In Milwaukee, Wis., the Lakefront Brewery (www.lakefrontbrewery.com) has supported Slow Food through fundraisers and tastings, and it embodies the ethos in Local Acre, the first commercially sold beer to be made entirely from ingredients grown and processed in Wisconsin since Prohibition. Back in 2008, Lakefront was featured in the beer pavilion at the Slow Food Nation festival in San Francisco, which saw roughly 85,000 attendees in all."

Awesome!

Beers of the World


I cracked open the Beers of the World pack and looked at the contents.  There were a variety of bottles.  Newcastle and Modelo were clear glass.  Calsberg, moosehead and tsingtao were in tinted glass, but not dark.  Köstritzer, Sapporo, O.K. Beer Okocim, Bitburger and Kronenbourg 1664 were dark glass.

I've had Carlsber before.  It's okay.
I've had Newcastle before.  I like it.
I've had Tsingtao before.  I like it.

The rest are all new to me.  My only disappointment is that of 10 beers, they represent 9 countries.
Carlsberg - Denmark
Moosehead - Canada
Tsingtao - China
Modelo - Mexico
Newcastle - England
Sapporo - Japan
O.K. Beer Okocim - Poland
Kronenbourg 1664 - France
Köstritzer and Bitburger - Germany

Why does Germany get double representation.  There are so many other places out there that make beer.  Good beer.  Why isn't there Czech beer, Irish, the Netherlands.  Or maybe something a little further from the norm that we see in the US?  Brazil, or someplace in Africa?

Well, I guess I'm not really complaining.  If I really want to try out something else, there are so many places that do build-your-owns that if I decide to stop being lazy, I can go out and get exactly what I want.

More Fun From World Market

Yesterday we stopped at World Market to pick up a few things - We always impulse buy while there, so we don't go too often. Amanda picked up Framboise. She also decided to try Samuel Smith's Raspberry Organic Fruit Ale, which we've never had. I picked up their Beers of the World 10-pack sampler, of which 7 are new to me. Yay!

Saturday, April 23, 2011

A Moment for Cider

When I was in college a friend of mine was asked what his favorite beer was. He responded Woodchuck. His argument was that cider is a malt beverage and was therefore beer. I've always thought that was stupid. I understand there is a relationship between the two, but they're not the same. Nonetheless, I'm going to take a moment to step away from beer for a moment to talk about cider.

Last night we went out to celebrate Amanda's birthday. I'd had a couple of very good beers with dinner, and Amanda had a couple bottles of Magners (her favorite cider). After dinner, she didn't want to go out to a club since we'd gotten caught in the rain and her hair had fallen pretty badly. But she still wanted to go out, and she wanted Strongbow on tap. Strongbow is my favorite cider, and I'll drink it just about any way. But not a lot of places around here have cider on tap. So we went to Paddy's Irish pub. Friends of ours had introduced it to us a few years back, and it's a fantastic place with two great owners - Patty and Woody. Since we'd gone there for Strongbow, I switched to cider. When I first started drinking, I'd had Woodchuck. Which was okay, but it is very sweet. Then I found Strongbow, which I've always described as a dry cider. Well while drinking it last night, I realized that it is really darn sweet. Now I want to know why I ever bothered with something sweeter.

But I suppose part of that has to do with the fact that Woodchuck is a "gateway" cider. In the world of alcohol, there seems to be a trend of beverages that are okay, but popular. They end up introducing people to a type of beverage and then allow them to discover truly good versions. Woodchuck is just that kind of drink. Even though I don't drink it anymore, I wouldn't mind going back to it to see what I liked about it. Maybe I'll need to do a comparison test of cider sometime.

Milwaukee Beer Week

www.milwaukeebeerweek.com

Thursday April 28 - Sunday May 8
Including the Second Annual Milwaukee's Taste of Great Brewers on Friday April 28 at the Harley Davidson Museum

I'm not sure what the problem is but I didn't know about this event until this last week when I saw a pair of posters in my local Pick'N'Save when I stopped in for some tartar sauce and a six pack of Capital Maibock. (This was not the same PNS I called out for not carrying it - the one I was at this time was near 70th and National near downtown 'Stallis.) as I was exiting through the liquor department doors, I see these two posters, and I snapped a poor phone photo so I don't forget.

Well for those of you in or around the Milwaukee area - get out there and have a beer! Support this week and the Breweries, Bars, Restaurants and Stores that make drinking a fine beer in this city available to you.

The drawback - the website's events list. It doesn't clearly indicate where a lot of these events are and the time's provided seem almost arbitrary, since you'll get a time for events that are "all week". And it's not clear how that participant figures the week. The dates for MBW are longer than seven day, but are businesses participating those dates or the Sun - Sat of the actual full week? How can the working man or woman plan to take part is this isn't clear?

Sunday, April 17, 2011

In Defense of Big Beer

I Was reading an article in my latest issue of Beer Connoisseur magazine and I was starting an article about pilsners. Now, granted, this is a magazine that is about craft beer and an appreciation of things on the more sophisticated end of the beer spectrum - but in pointing out that the modern American pilsner is far different and less flavorful than a "true" pilsner, the other seemed to go on and on about the inferiority of the popular American macro-brewed beers.

I felt the need to say something in defense of the Miller Lites, Budweisers, Coors Lights and all the rest. Which some may find funny, because if we go out and that's what you order, I'm likely to make fun of you. But let's be honest - Big Beer deserves a little respect.

Do craft beers keep your local pub in business? Doubtful at best.
Do they provide any sponsorship for events you care about? Unless it is a beer-specific event, then rarely
If you are tight on cash, will you be happy to settle for a less expensive beer rather than go without. Most people do.
When you first met beer, were you and craft beer an exclusive item? Not for most people.
At sporting event do you drink a macro brew? Most of you probably do - even those of you that shell out the big bucks on craft beers for the first couple that you drink.
What about distribution - craft beers will sometimes partner with big breweries to increase their distribution abilities (Leinenkugels with Miller-Coors).
For all of beer's fine history, it has always been the beverage of the masses, and what beers make up the vast majority of beers consumed? Not craft beers.

I'm not saying that craft beer needs to try to be like its big brother - goodness no. And I'm not saying it's what I want to drink. But I think we all owe it a lot of respect. And I think it is well past time for craft beer lovers to stop insulting big beer just to help emphasize how wonderful it is. Talk about the differences, by all means. And I'm not saying the jokes and the insults about Macro brews should stop (I won't stop), but craft beers are a legitimate part of the industry in their own right, and do not need to put down their larger, more common counterparts to gain legitimacy.

Thursday, March 24, 2011

Milwaukee Ale House

On Saturday, March 19th, Amanda and I went to the Milwaukee Ale House for lunch. This was my first time, but I've been planning to go since I'd found out that it was on several of OnMilwaukee.com's "best" lists.

They have two potential six beer samplers - the Light Flight and the Night Flight:

Light Flight
1) Ulao Wit
2) Flaming Damsel
3) Downtown Lites
4) Solomon Juneau
5) Pullchain Pail Ale
6) Dunkel-Weizen

Night Flight
1) Downtown Lites
2) Flaming Damsel
3) Pullchain Pail Ale
4) Louie's Demise
5) Blockhead Brown
6) Sheepshead Stout

They also allow you to add a seventh sample for an extra dollar from any of their draft beers. This was nor the extent of their beers available, but I had come with the intention of sampling. I chose the night flight (promising myself to return for the Light Flight) and after it arrived, I decided to add a Pressing 78 Porter. Amanda ordered their Bloody Mary and received a chaser of the Solomon Juneau. The menu had a 1-4 hopiness scale (1 - Hint O' Hop, 4 - Lots O' Hop). And they gave the following descriptions:

Louie's Demise 4.8%
Medium bodied amber ale with hints of caramel and roasted malt.
Hop scale: 3

Pullchain Pail Ale 5.0%
Smooth, hoppy ale with citrus spice notes. 43 BUs.
Hop scale: 4

Flaming Damsel 4.8%
A copper hued Vienna Style lager with a rich malt flavor.
Hop scale: 2

Solomon Juneau Ale 5.0%
A crisp hoppy golden ale with a fresh citrus aroma.
Hop scale: 3

Downtown Lites 4.5%
Refreshingly balanced honey ale.
Hop scale: 1

Sheepshead Stout 6.0%
Classic Oatmeal stout, teaming wit rich coffee and chocolate flavors. Nitrogen tapped.
Hop scale: 2

Pressing 78 Porter 5.6%
A rich mahogany ale with warm malt flavors and hints of raisins.
Hop scale: 3

Blockhead Brown Ale 5.3%
A light bodied aenglish pub brown ale with milk chocolate, caramel and his hit flavors
Hop scale: 2

My preferences were as follows (#1 being my favorite):
#1 - Pressing 78 Porter
#2 - Sheepshead Stout
#3 - Pullchain Pail Ale
#4 - Blockhead Brown
#5 - Flaming Damsel
#6 - Solomon Juneau Ale
#7 - Downtown Lites
#8 - Louie's Demise

Now don't misunderstand - just because their flagship brew (Louie's Demise) is at the bottom of my list, I am not saying I don't like it. I am quite happy to say that I liked every beer I tried and am comfortable calling each of them a good beer.

I also tried to rate each beer independently on a scale of one to ten. One being unimpressive and ten being Great.
Downtown Lites: 8
Flaming Damsel: 5-6
Pullchain Pale Ale: 4
Louie's Demise: 6
Blockhead Brown: 7
Sheepshead Stout: 5
Pressing 78 Porter: 7-8
Solomon Juneau Ale: 6

Now don't get confused by my choosing the Sheepshead Stout as my second favorite, but only rating it as a 5 out of ten.

With my favorites list I asked myself, "Of these beers in front of me, which is most likely to get ordered and drunk in multiples during one visit (or sitting if I get a six pack)?"

With the rating, I asked myself, "When I am in the mood to drink this style of beer, how likely am I to choose it over another brewer's?"

To continue using the Sheepshead Stout as an example, I would gladly grab a seat at the bar and drink 2-3 pints of it. But if I were to pick up a Stout from the store, I may be more likely to get a Guiness, Beamish, or Murphy's.

Hmm. Now I want to do a side-by-side stout tasting to see if it's true.