OnMilwaukee.com lists the top Milwaukee brew pub each year. I think it may be a good list for me to use to try new places. I am ashamed to say that I have only tried 2 of them, and not even any of the top 3.
Milwaukee's best brew pubs - 2010
1. Lakefront Brewery Palm Garden
2. Milwaukee Ale House (rated #1 in 2009)
3. Hinterland
4. Rock Bottom Brewery (DONE)
5. Water Street Brewery (DONE)
6. Stonefly Brewing Co.
7. Bay View Brew Haus
8. St. Francis Brewery
9. Delafield Brewhaus
10. Grafton Ale House
11. Port Washington Brewing Co.
12. Riverside Brewery
